The Verdict

Four AI jurors take your business idea apart. Then a judge tells you to build it, pivot it or kill it.

Free · no sign-up · about 10 minutes from pitch to verdict

Each juror reviews your idea separately and looks at one thing only, so nobody gives you polite, balanced, useless feedback. Then the judge hears them all and has the final word.

Meet the panel

The Investor

Early-stage investor

“Is the market big enough for what you want, and what stops someone copying you in three months?”

The Customer

Your target customer, simulated

“Would I actually switch from what I use today - and pay your price for it?”

has the final word

the judge

Hears all four reviews, then rules on every concern
Upholds, downgrades or overrules - and says why
Never averages the votes
One real deal-breaker outweighs any number of strengths

The Operator

Serial founder

“Can you build this with your skills, hours and budget? Where do the first 100 customers come from?”

The Skeptic

Devil's advocate

“Why hasn't this worked before, and which assumption makes the whole thing collapse?”

See how it works

1
Pitch it
The problem, the customer, the money and you. About five minutes.
2
Get interviewed
A mentor asks only what your pitch left unclear - and digs deeper if your answers raise new questions.
3
Market research
A live web search for real competitors, failed attempts and prices.
4
The panel
Four jurors review it independently, each from one angle only.
5
The verdict
The judge rules on every concern and decides: build, pivot or kill.

A real verdict · EdgeTips · 57/100

The edge may be real. The offer math is not.

“You have built a plausible betting model, not yet a sellable subscription. At 16 bets a month and a 4.8% return, a customer staking £20 expects £15.36 before paying your £19 fee. That turns an edge into a loss.”

Every verdict comes with a scorecard, your defenses judged, a money check, real competitors and a 14-day plan.

Read the full verdict

Real reports from the real panel, on sample pitches. No sign-up needed to read them.

See all examples